Collegiate Players of the Past and Present
* senior captain
Your help is needed. Please email sealsfh@ptd.net with respect to any corrections or other information about players, honors, and awards, while in college and anything else that should be added to our website. If we missed you, we apologize and we look forward to a more comprehensive listing.
| Year of Graduation | Player | College |
| 23 | Cassidy Kibler | Indiana University of PA |
| 23 | Sydney Schmouder | Indiana University of PA |
| 22 | Riley Batdorf | Mansfield |
| 22 | Julie Mcgovern | Lycoming |
| 22 | Isa Napoli | Susquehanna |
| 22 | Leah Toskey | Mansfield |
| 21 | Jess Alba | Widener |
| 21 | Hailey Bingaman | Wilkes |
| 21 | Hannah Day | Juniata |
| 21 | Rachel Martin | Wilkes |
| 21 | Olivia Reichley | Wilkes - Indiana University of PA |
| 21 | Marley Showers | Wilkes |
| 20 | *Katie Bucher | Susquehanna |
| 20 | Maddie Bucher | Lynchburg |
| 20 | Emily Swineford | Bloomsburg |
| 19 | Maura Hensel | Wilkes |
| 19 | Megan Hoffman | American |
| 19 | Elise Keeney | Moravian |
| 19 | Anna Piecuch | Lehigh |
| 19 | *SaraMae Radel | Mansfield |
| 19 | Camryn Ritter | Bloomsburg |
| 19 | Kalee Rothermel | Juniata |
| 19 | Morgan Ruhl | Eastern |
| 18 | *Danielle Alba | Lebanon Valley |
| 17 | Savannah Bucher | Indiana |
| 17 | Megan Keeney | Bucknell - Kean |
| 17 | Jess Smith | Susquehanna - Mary Washington |
| 16 | Abby Batchelder | York |
| 16 | *Tesa Hoffman | Bloomsburg |
| 16 | Lexi Horst | Penn State |
| 15 | *Nora Aucker | Indiana |
| 15 | Emily Klingler | Penn State |
| 15 | Caitlin Redd | Misericordia |
| 15 | Megan Wetzel | Messiah |
| 15 | Brooke Zeiders | Shippensburg - Bloomsburg |
| 14 | Becca Bausinger | Shippensburg |
| 14 | Katelyn Hauck | Ursinus |
| 14 | Geneka Mahan | Bloomsburg |
| 14 | MacKenna Mahan | Bloomsburg |
| 13 | Jenna Kapsar | Miami-Ohio |
| 12 | Jesse Davis | American |
| 12 | Nicole Deckard | Longwood |
| 12 | *Haley Kerstetter | Penn State |
| 12 | Danielle Reber | Susquehanna |
| 11 | Paige Bordner | Kent State |
| 11 | Karrie Hauck | Susquehanna |
| 11 | Rachael Lawton | Wesley |
| 11 | Candice Smith | Bloomsburg |
| 11 | Danika Watto | Misericordia |
| 11 | Ashley Youngman | Indiana University of PA |
| 10 | Hope Burke | Stanford |
| 10 | Ashtin Klingler | Syracuse-Penn State |
| 10 | Gina Kellett | Messiah |
| 10 | Amber Wendt | Indiana University of PA |
| 10 | Katie Walborn | New Hampshire |
| 09 | *Danica Deckard | Ohio State |
| 09 | Mallory Pope | East Stroudsburg |
| 09 | Arianna White | Slippery Rock |
| 08 | Alyssa Moyer | Louisville-Lock Haven |
| 08 | Kirsten Krebs | Yale |
| 08 | Morgan Fleetwood | Indiana |
| 07 | Alicia Mayer | University of Michigan |
| 07 | *Bri Doak | Ohio State |
| 07 | Rachel Hollenbach | Louisville |
| 07 | Taryn Nichols | Temple |
| 07 | Kylee Yetter | Temple |
| 06 | Ashley Oswald | Messiah |
| 06 | Courtney Salsman | Susquehanna Univ. |
| 05 | Allie Ziants | Bloomsburg |
| 05 | Steph Aucker | Lock Haven Univ. |
| 05 | Anne Ritter | Gettysburg |
| 03 | Sam Geiswite | Immaculata |
| 03 | Jess Rogers | Ursinus |
| 03 | Laura Rinck | Elizabethtown |
| 03 | Katie Williams | Connecticut |
| 00 | Carli Bordner | Shippensburg |
| 00 | Jodie Dagle | Susquehanna Univ. |
| 00 | Kira Fisher | Shippensburg |
| 00 | Lisa Bingaman | Bucknell |
| 98 | Barbie Wirtz | Elizabethtown |
| 97 | Keli Smith | Maryland |
| 97 | Mandy Houser | Millersville |
| 96 | Traci Anselmo | Penn State Univ. |
| 96 | Holly Miller | Franklin & Marshall |
| 95 | Bev Hartley | Bloomsburg Univ. |
| 94 | Stacy Dagle | Misercordia |
| 94 | Alexa Houser | Ithica |
| 92 | Michelle Troutman | Elizabethtown |
| 92 | Jeni Bowersox | Muhlenberg |
| 92 | Andrea Weaver | Susquehanna Univ. |
| 92 | Tracy Wilcox | Loch Haven Univ. |
| 91 | Tracey Corrigan | Susquehanna Univ. |
| 91 | Cheri Long | Susquehanna Univ. |
| 91 | Heather Krouse | Franklin and Marshall |
| 91 | Nikki Bush | Lock Haven |
| 90 | Kara Smith | Ursinus |
| 90 | Amy Troutman | Gettysburg |
| 89 | Tammy Mull | Susquehanna Univ. |
| 88 | Deann Blankenship | Susquehanna Univ. |
| 88 | Jan Corrigan | Loyola |
| 87 | Tanna Charles | Millersville |
| 87 | Shannon Rothermel | Millersville |
| 87 | Becky Kerstetter | Millersville |
| 87 | Amy Troup | Susquehanna Univ. |
| 87 | Missy Burd Bingaman | Lock Haven |
| 86 | Linda Meiser | Muhlenberg |
| 85 | Brenda Doebler | Cedar Crest |
| 78 | Brenda Gibson | Lafayette |
| 77 | Cathy Leitzel | Lock Haven University |